This Christmas cake batter cookie became a holiday staple the year I decided to create a showstopper cookie for our neighborhood cookie swap. I first tasted a similar version at a café and was determined to reproduce that pillowy texture and concentrated cake-batter aroma at home. After several test batches, the balance of butter, sugar and a touch of cake batter extract was perfect: the cookie is tender, slightly cakey around the edges, with a soft center that holds up beautifully to a generous swirl of buttercream. The festive sprinkles add crunch and color without overwhelming the delicate vanilla-cake flavor.

I discovered this formula on a chilly November afternoon while wrapping presents and craving something sweet that looked as joyful as the season felt. What makes these cookies special is the frosting method: a silky, vanilla-forward buttercream that can be piped into tall swirls, just like the bakery-style presentation. They slice clean in half if you prefer sandwich cookies, but my family loves piling the frosting high and finishing them with more sprinkles. Small rituals — like pressing a single star sprinkle on top of each cookie for my youngest — turned these into a holiday tradition.

Ingredients

• Baking powder & salt: 3 teaspoons baking powder and 1 teaspoon salt create a gentle lift and even crumb. Use aluminum-free baking powder for cleaner flavor; I like Rumford for consistent results.
• All-purpose flour: 4 cups. Spoon and level into the cup to avoid dense dough. King Arthur or a high-quality all-purpose flour gives a reliable structure.
• Unsalted butter: 1 1/2 cups for the dough and 1 cup for the frosting. Room temperature butter (soft but not oily) creams better and traps air for a lighter bite; plug-ins like European-style butter are optional if you want richer flavor.
• Sugars: 1 1/4 cups granulated sugar plus 1/4 cup packed light brown sugar for a hint of chew and depth. Measure the brown sugar firmly for consistent moisture.
• Eggs: 2 large eggs add structure and moisture; use room-temperature eggs so the batter emulsifies smoothly.
• Cake batter extract: 2 teaspoons in the dough and 1/2 teaspoon in the frosting for that unmistakable carnival-cake aroma. LorAnn and Nielsen-Massey make concentrated versions; start with small amounts and taste.
• Holiday sprinkles: 1 cup. Choose high-quality jimmies or nonpareils; larger confetti sprinkles can bleed color so pat dry if wet.
• Powdered sugar & heavy cream: 5 cups powdered sugar and 2 to 4 tablespoons heavy cream to build a smooth pipeable buttercream.

Instructions

Preheat and prepare: Preheat the oven to 350°F. Line baking sheets with parchment paper or silicone mats to prevent spreading and ensure even browning. If you plan to bake multiple sheets, rotate them halfway through baking for consistent color. Combine dry ingredients: Whisk together 3 teaspoons baking powder, 1 teaspoon salt, and 4 cups all-purpose flour in a medium bowl. Sifting is optional but helps remove lumps and aerates the flour for a lighter cookie. Cream butter and sugars: In a stand mixer fitted with the paddle, beat 1 1/2 cups softened unsalted butter with 1 1/4 cups granulated sugar and 1/4 cup packed light brown sugar on low-medium until fluffy and pale, about 2 to 3 minutes. Scrape the bowl to ensure even creaming. Incorporate eggs and extract: Add 2 large eggs one at a time, mixing until combined, then blend in 2 teaspoons cake batter extract. Mixing at medium speed helps form a stable emulsion; avoid overbeating once the flour is added. Add dry ingredients: With the mixer on low, slowly add the flour mixture and mix just until the dough comes together. Stop as soon as you no longer see streaks of flour to keep the cookies tender. Fold in sprinkles: Gently stir in 1 cup holiday sprinkles by hand or on low speed to prevent color bleed. If using large confetti sprinkles, fold carefully so they stay intact and maintain their shape. Portion and shape: Scoop 2 to 3 tablespoon balls of dough onto prepared sheets, spacing 3 to 4 inches apart depending on size. For a bakery-style flat top, press each ball slightly with the bottom of a glass; for more domed cookies, leave them untouched. Bake and cool: Bake 13–16 minutes for 2-tablespoon cookies or 18–20 minutes for 3-tablespoon cookies. Edges should be lightly golden and tops no longer glossy. Transfer to a rack and cool completely before frosting to prevent melting the buttercream. Make the frosting: In a large bowl, beat 1 cup softened unsalted butter until smooth. Gradually add 5 cups powdered sugar until crumbly, then add 1/2 teaspoon cake batter extract and 1/4 teaspoon salt. Add 2 tablespoons heavy cream and beat until light and fluffy, adding up to 2 more tablespoons to reach a pipeable consistency. Frost and decorate: Fit a piping bag with a round tip to replicate bakery swirls. Pipe concentric rounds to build height, or spread with a knife for a more casual look. Finish with extra sprinkles while the frosting is soft.

Storage Tips

Store assembled cookies in a single layer or in layers separated by parchment in an airtight container. At room temperature they keep well for up to three days; refrigeration extends life to about a week but may firm the buttercream. For long-term storage, freeze unfrosted cookies in a tight container for up to three months. Thaw completely before frosting; if frosting frozen cookies, allow them to come to room temperature on the counter to avoid condensation on the frosting.

Ingredient Substitutions

If you cannot find cake batter extract, substitute with 1 teaspoon vanilla extract plus 1/4 teaspoon almond extract for a similar nostalgic profile. For dairy-free adaptations use vegan butter and a non-dairy cream alternative — note texture will be slightly different and the frosting may be softer. Gluten-free flour blends can replace all-purpose in a 1:1 ratio, but choose a blend labeled for baking and chill the dough longer to reduce spread.

Serving Suggestions

Serve these cookies on a holiday platter with assorted flavors: include a chocolate-dipped version, a plain frosted one, and a sprinkled classic to give variety. Pair with hot cocoa, eggnog, or a simple black coffee to balance sweetness. For gifting, stack three cookies in a small box with tissue paper and a ribbon for a polished presentation.

Cultural Background

Novelty cookies flavored to mimic cake batter have roots in modern American baking where extract and emulsion technology expanded flavor options. The playful, confectionery style is popular in pastry shops and viral baking trends, reflecting a love for nostalgic carnival and birthday-cake notes. These cookies borrow that nostalgic flavor and marry it to a classic American butter cookie base, offering a festive twist on time-honored holiday baking.

Seasonal Adaptations

To adapt across seasons, swap the sprinkles for pastel tones in spring or for orange and brown jimmies in autumn. Add 1/2 teaspoon ground ginger and a pinch of cinnamon for winter-spiced warmth. For a summer version, fold in 1/2 cup finely chopped freeze-dried strawberries and use a light strawberry buttercream instead of cake batter extract.

Meal Prep Tips

Prepare dough up to 48 hours ahead and refrigerate; scoop onto trays and keep covered so it’s ready to bake. You can also portion dough into balls on a sheet, flash-freeze, then transfer to a bag — bake from frozen, adding 1–2 minutes. For frosting, make the buttercream ahead and chill; bring to room temperature and re-whip before piping to restore texture.

These cookies are more than a festive treat; they are a memory-maker. I hope you find as much joy baking and sharing them as I have — from the first whiff of cake-batter extract to the final sprinkle on top.

Happy baking from flavest — and may your holidays be sweet and full of warmth.